What happened to Windows Installer 4.1?

  • Article

For a time, there was a release named Windows Installer 4.1 on the MSDN topic Released Versions of Windows Installer that was associated with Windows Vista SP1 and Windows Server 2008.  When this reference to 4.1 was removed, it naturally lead to the question: what happened to Windows Installer 4.1?

The back story here starts about this time last year when we were finishing up Windows Installer 4.0 in Windows Vista and asking ourselves "What's next?". At that time, we didn't know the bar for features in Windows Vista SP1 and next major release of Windows.  For those of you watching Microsoft closely at the time, you may recall this is when there was a lot of change going on in the upper echelons of Windows

We also had the seeds of an out of band release germinating in the organization.

In this fluid context, we had to figure out names for what appeared to be three simultaneous efforts from the Windows Installer team.  Knowing none of the feature and release criteria, our best guess at the time was that Windows Vista SP1 would ship first, an out of band release would ship next, and then the next full version of Windows would be our focus.  With this guess at timelines, we chose the names Windows Installer 4.1, Windows Installer 4.5, and Windows Installer 5.0 as the labels for the next three buckets of work from the Windows Installer team.

It just so happened that at this same time, the Windows Vista version of the Platform SDK was finishing up.  Given our best guess was that we'd be doing significant work in Windows Vista SP1, we added the reference to Windows Installer 4.1 for anticipatory completeness.

What changed was that the new guard in Windows had a very different bar for the Vista SP than had been in practice for previous releases (at least in my memory).  Generally there is lip service to no large feature work in a SP but this time folks listened.  Big feature adds were heavily scrutinized.  The items we wanted to fix in the SP, UAC tweaks, were big feature by the new bar. 

When the UAC tweaks were rejected for Vista SP1, the justification for 4.1 faded as there were no new features in the Windows Installer in Vista SP1.

[Author: Robert Flaming]
This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights. Use of included script samples are subject to the terms specified at https://www.microsoft.com/info/cpyright.htm.

Comments

  • Anonymous
    October 01, 2007
    PingBack from http://www.artofbam.com/wordpress/?p=4277

  • Anonymous
    October 02, 2007
    Wny of why doesn't windows have a package management system of some kind that checks dependencies and allows you to do things like check the md5 sums of all the files a package installed, centrally? Every major OS in the universe, except windows, has a built in package manager.  

  • Anonymous
    October 02, 2007
    Any chance of shipping the MSI runtime outside of the SP?  This used to be how things were done in the past. After all, most setup developers have very long lists of wishes that never seem to make it into a release.

  • Anonymous
    October 02, 2007
    @Scott Marlowe Have you ever heared about Windows Update?

  • Anonymous
    October 03, 2007
    >Have you ever heared about Windows Update? Windows Update works for Microsoft Expression Blend, Corel Painter and Lingvo? NO WAI!!