Transparent Data Encryption

You can take several precautions to help secure the database such as designing a secure system, encrypting confidential assets, and building a firewall around the database servers. However, for a scenario in which the physical media (such as drives or backup tapes) are stolen, a malicious party can just restore or attach the database and browse the data. One solution is to encrypt the sensitive data in the database and protect the keys that are used to encrypt the data with a certificate. This prevents anyone without the keys from using the data, but this kind of protection must be planned in advance.

Transparent data encryption (TDE) performs real-time I/O encryption and decryption of the data and transaction log files and the special PDW log files. The encryption uses a database encryption key (DEK), which is stored in the database boot record for availability during recovery. The DEK is a symmetric key secured by using a certificate stored in the master database of the SQL Server PDW. TDE protects data "at rest", meaning the data and log files. It provides the ability to comply with many laws, regulations, and guidelines established in various industries. This feature enables software developers to encrypt data by using AES and 3DES encryption algorithms without changing existing applications.

After it is secured, the database can be restored by using the correct certificate.

Encryption of the database file is performed at the page level. The pages in an encrypted database are encrypted before they are written to disk and decrypted when read into memory. TDE does not increase the size of the encrypted database.

The following illustration shows the hierarchy of keys for TDE encryption:

Using Transparent Data Encryption

To use TDE, follow these steps. The first three steps are only done once, when preparing SQL Server PDW to support TDE.

1. Create a master key in the master database.

2. Use sp_pdw_database_encryption to enable TDE on the SQL Server PDW. This operation modifies the temporary databases in order to ensure the protection of future temporary data, and will fail if attempted when there are any active sessions that have temporary tables. sp_pdw_database_encryption turns on user data masking in PDW system logs. (For more information about user data masking in PDW system logs, see sp_pdw_log_user_data_masking.)

3. Use sp_pdw_add_network_credentials to create a credential that can authenticate and write to the share where the backup of the certificate will be stored. If a credential already exists for the intended storage server, you can use the existing credential.

4. In the master database, create a certificate protected by the master key.

5. Back up the certificate to the storage share.

6. In the user database, create a database encryption key and protect it by the certificate that is stored in the master database.

7. Use the ALTER DATABASE statement to encrypt the database using TDE.

The following example illustrates encrypting the AdventureWorksPDW2012 database using a certificate named MyServerCert, created in SQL Server PDW.

First: Enable TDE on the SQL Server PDW. This action is only necessary once.

USE master;  
GO  
  
-- Create a database master key in the master database  
CREATE MASTER KEY ENCRYPTION BY PASSWORD = '<UseStrongPasswordHere>';  
GO  
  
-- Enable encryption for PDW  
EXEC sp_pdw_database_encryption 1;  
GO  
  
-- Add a credential that can write to the share  
-- A credential created for a backup can be used if you wish  
EXEC sp_pdw_add_network_credentials 'SECURE_SERVER', '<domain>\<Windows_user>', '<password>';  

Second: Create and backup a certificate in the master database. This action is only required once. You can have a separate certificate for each database (recommended), or you can protect multiple databases with one certificate.

-- Create certificate in master  
CREATE CERTIFICATE MyServerCert WITH SUBJECT = 'My DEK Certificate';  
GO  
  
-- Back up the certificate with private key  
BACKUP CERTIFICATE MyServerCert   
    TO FILE = '\\SECURE_SERVER\cert\MyServerCert.cer'  
    WITH PRIVATE KEY   
    (   
        FILE = '\\SECURE_SERVER\cert\MyServerCert.key',  
        ENCRYPTION BY PASSWORD = '<UseStrongPasswordHere>'   
    )   
GO  

Last: Create the DEK and use ALTER DATABASE to encrypt a user database. This action is repeated for each database that is protected by TDE.

USE AdventureWorksPDW2012;  
GO  
  
CREATE DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY  
WITH ALGORITHM = AES_128  
ENCRYPTION BY SERVER CERTIFICATE MyServerCert;  
GO  
  
ALTER DATABASE AdventureWorksPDW2012 SET ENCRYPTION ON;  
GO  

The encryption and decryption operations are scheduled on background threads by SQL Server. You can view the status of these operations using the catalog views and dynamic management views in the list that appears later in this article.

Commands and Functions

The TDE certificates must be encrypted by the database master key to be accepted by the following statements.

The following table provides links and explanations of TDE commands and functions.

Catalog Views and Dynamic Management Views

The following table shows TDE catalog views and dynamic management views.

Permissions

Each TDE feature and command has individual permission requirements, described in the tables shown earlier.

Viewing the metadata involved with TDE requires the CONTROL SERVER permission.

Considerations

While a re-encryption scan for a database encryption operation is in progress, maintenance operations to the database are disabled.

You can find the state of the database encryption using the sys.dm_pdw_nodes_database_encryption_keys dynamic management view. For more information, see the Catalog Views and Dynamic Management Views section earlier in this article.

Restrictions

The following operations are not allowed during the CREATE DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY, ALTER DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY, DROP DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY, or ALTER DATABASE...SET ENCRYPTION statements.

• Dropping the database.

• Using an ALTER DATABASE command.

• Starting a database backup.

• Starting a database restore.

The following operations or conditions will prevent the CREATE DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY, ALTER DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY, DROP DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY, or ALTER DATABASE...SET ENCRYPTION statements.

• An ALTER DATABASE command is executing.

• Any data backup is running.

When creating database files, instant file initialization is not available when TDE is enabled.

Areas Not Protected by TDE

TDE does not protect external tables.

TDE does not protect diagnostic sessions. Users should be careful not to queries with sensitive parameters while diagnostic sessions are in use. Diagnostic sessions that reveal sensitive information should be dropped as soon as they are no longer needed.

Data protected by TDE is decrypted when placed in SQL Server PDW memory. Memory dumps are created when certain problems occur on appliance. Dump files represent the content of the memory at the time of the problem appearance and can contain sensitive data in an unencrypted form. The content of memory dumps should be reviewed before they are shared with others.

The master database is not protected by TDE. Though the master database does not contain user data, it does contain information such as login names.

Transparent Data Encryption and Transaction Logs

Enabling a database to use TDE has the effect of zeroing out the remaining part of the virtual transaction log to force the next virtual transaction log. This guarantees that no clear text is left in the transaction logs after the database is set for encryption. You can find the status of the log file encryption on each PDW node by viewing the encryption_state column in the sys.dm_pdw_nodes_database_encryption_keys view, as in this example:

WITH dek_encryption_state AS   
(  
    SELECT ISNULL(db_map.database_id, dek.database_id) AS database_id, encryption_state  
    FROM sys.dm_pdw_nodes_database_encryption_keys AS dek  
        INNER JOIN sys.pdw_nodes_pdw_physical_databases AS node_db_map  
           ON dek.database_id = node_db_map.database_id AND dek.pdw_node_id = node_db_map.pdw_node_id  
        LEFT JOIN sys.pdw_database_mappings AS db_map  
            ON node_db_map .physical_name = db_map.physical_name  
        INNER JOIN sys.dm_pdw_nodes AS nodes  
            ON nodes.pdw_node_id = dek.pdw_node_id  
    WHERE dek.encryptor_thumbprint <> 0x  
)  
SELECT TOP 1 encryption_state  
       FROM dek_encryption_state  
       WHERE dek_encryption_state.database_id = DB_ID('AdventureWorksPDW2012 ')  
       ORDER BY (CASE encryption_state WHEN 3 THEN -1 ELSE encryption_state END) DESC;  

All data written to the transaction log before a change in the database encryption key will be encrypted by using the previous database encryption key.

PDW Activity Logs

SQL Server PDW maintains a set of logs intended for troubleshooting. (Note, this is not the transaction log, the SQL Server error log, or the Windows event log.) These PDW activity logs can contain full statements in clear text, some of which can contain user data. Typical examples are INSERT and UPDATE statements. Masking of user data can be explicitly turned on or off by using sp_pdw_log_user_data_masking. Enabling encryption on SQL Server PDW automatically turns on the masking of user data in PDW activity logs in order to protect them. sp_pdw_log_user_data_masking can also be used to mask statements when not using TDE, but that is not recommended because it significantly reduces the ability of the Microsoft Support Team to analyze problems.

Transparent Data Encryption and the tempdb System Database

The tempdb system database is encrypted when encryption is enabled by using sp_pdw_database_encryption. This is required before any database can use TDE. This might have a performance effect for unencrypted databases on the same instance of SQL Server PDW.

Key Management

The database encryption key (DEK) is protected by the certificates stored in the master database. These certificates are protected by the database master key (DMK) of the master database. The DMK needs to be protected by the service master key (SMK) in order to be used for TDE.

The system can access the keys without requiring human intervention (such as providing a password). If the certificate is not available, the system will output an error explaining that the DEK cannot be decrypted until the proper certificate is available.

When moving a database from one appliance to another, the certificate used to protect its' DEK must be restored first on the destination server. Then the database can be restored as usual. For more information, see the standard SQL Server documentation, at Move a TDE Protected Database to Another SQL Server.

Certificates used to encrypt DEKs should be retained as long as there are database backups that use them. Certificate backups must include the certificate private key, because without the private key a certificate cannot be used for database restore. Those certificate private key backups are stored in a separate file, protected by a password that must be provided for certificate restore.

Restoring the master Database

The master database can be restored using DWConfig, as part of the disaster recovery.

• If the control node hasn't changed, that is if the master database is restored on the same and unchanged appliance from which the backup of master database was taken, the DMK and all the certificates will be readable without additional action.

• If the master database is restored on a different appliance, or if the control node has been changed since the backup of the master database, additional steps will be required in order to regenerate the DMK.

  1. Open the DMK:

     OPEN MASTER KEY DECRYPTION BY PASSWORD = '<password>';  
     

  2. Add the encryption by SMK:

     ALTER MASTER KEY   
         ADD ENCRYPTION BY SERVICE MASTER KEY;  
     

  3. Restart the appliance.

Upgrade and Replacing Virtual Machines

If a DMK exists on the appliance on which Upgrade or Replace VM was performed, DMK password must be provided as a parameter.

Example of the upgrade action. Replace ********** with your DMK password.

setup.exe /Action=ProvisionUpgrade ... DMKPassword='**********'

Example of the action to replace a virtual machine.

setup.exe /Action=ReplaceVM ... DMKPassword='**********'

During upgrade, if a user DB is encrypted and the DMK password is not provided, the upgrade action will fail. During replace, if the correct password is not provided when a DMK exists, the operation will skip the DMK recovery step. All the other steps will be completed at the end of the replace VM action, however the action will report failure at the end to indicate that additional steps are required. In the setup logs (located in \ProgramData\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server Parallel Data Warehouse\100\Logs\Setup\\<time-stamp>\Detail-Setup), the following warning will be shown near the end.

*** WARNING \*\*\* DMK is detected in master database, but could not be recovered automatically! The DMK password was either not provided or is incorrect!

Execute these statement manually in PDW and restart appliance after that in order to recover DMK:

OPEN MASTER KEY DECRYPTION BY PASSWORD = '<DMK password>';  
ALTER MASTER KEY ADD ENCRYPTION BY SERVICE MASTER KEY;  

Use the steps in the Restoring the master Database paragraph to recover the database, and then restart the appliance.

If the DMK existed before but was not recovered after the action, the following error message will be raised when a database is queried.

Msg 110806;  
A distributed query failed: Database '<db_name>' cannot be opened due to inaccessible files or insufficient memory or disk space. See the SQL Server errorlog for details.

Performance Impact

The performance impact of TDE varies with the type of data you have, how it is stored, and the type of workload activity on the SQL Server PDW. When protected by TDE, the I/O of reading and then decrypting data or the encrypting and then writing data is a CPU intensive activity and will have more impact when other CPU intensive activities are happening at the same time. Because TDE encrypts tempdb, TDE can affect the performance of databases that are not encrypted. To get an accurate idea of performance, you should test the entire system with your data and query activity.

Related Content

The following links contain general information about how SQL Server manages encryption. These articles can help you understand SQL Server encryption, but these articles do not have information specific to SQL Server PDW and they discuss features that are not present in SQL Server PDW.

• SQL Server Encryption

• Encryption Hierarchy

• SQL Server and Database Encryption Keys

See Also

ALTER DATABASE
CREATE MASTER KEY
CREATE DATABASE ENCRYPTION KEY
BACKUP CERTIFICATE
sp_pdw_database_encryption
sp_pdw_database_encryption_regenerate_system_keys
sp_pdw_log_user_data_masking
sys.certificates
sys.dm_pdw_nodes_database_encryption_keys