The Authenticator app is requesting a code from the app itself

I actually just had a similar issue but I actually got a new phone. I tried to get my companies IT department to help but they couldn’t figure it out. So I did myself. You will need to go online to the Microsoft website and log in with your work/company account. Then go to settings and remove the device then re add it. Use the drop-down to select app authentication. It will walk you through the process and give you the QR code again. Hope this helps. It’ll also allow your to set it up for text as a backup.

Hi, I'm having the same problem as Marc Lacombe. Also, when I try to access the "Security Info" section on My Account in order to add/remove devices it is also asking me for a code from the Microsoft Authenticator app which I cannot set up. Please help as this is blocking me from everyday work.

Hello, I got in touch with the Microsoft guys. Surprisingly just using the 'chat now' they got a hold of me and we did a Teams (well, 2 to be honest).

Turns out there is 2 settings for the security. One that is like for super user and another one that is like for super-super users. So we had to go to azure portal first since we have an azure account (as well as a microsoft 365 one) and on the main page, you go to Microsoft Intra Id (its a icon like a pyramid). On the left menu Properties, at the bottom of the page that opens you see the Security default. You need to click the Manage Security Default and then on the complete right of the screen, it shows how to disable the multi-factor auth.

So what this does is that it disables the 2 step authentication for everything. That's the super-super user function.

Then, if you go to your microsoft 365 admin center, if you go to Active Users (menu left) you can then click on the Multi-factor authentication that appears at the top. This allows you to set per person. However, to enable per person, you need to make sure that the first step was enabled. If you disabled it with the super-super user function, then nobody can enable the 2 step authentication. But once it is enabled in step 1, then you can set by user.

In our case, we had to disable like in step 1 and only then I stopped getting the message on my phone. Once I managed to install my account on the authenticator apps on my cell, then I could enable the 2 step authentication back again. I do suppose (not sure) that if a user only has Microsoft 365 the first step is not required, but as a test, one might still want to go to portal.azure.com to make sure. But its possible that the portal.office.com is sufficient.

I will admit its a bit complicated (and that's an understatement). Even the engineer at Microsoft had to think about it and it took a good 45 minutes over 2 calls to get it working. Over time, these systems have gotten huge but they are not making the customer's life any easier....

Hello, I have the same problem and it is not working. My computer asks me to enter a code on my cell and my cell keeps asking me to enter the code on my authenticator, while I am on the authenticator. I cannot even add my account on the authenticator. This is beyond discouraging, 5 hours lost already. Any help is welcome. I do have full admin rights on the microsoft account for all users and I can reset passwords, but its clearly not working

Finally I solved this issue !!!!

In my case it's COMPANY email address not personal.

---------- background

I had my company email account added into the Authenticator App on my personal phone.

Now I have a company phone, and wanted to move email from my personal phone to company phone.

But silly me, the email account was removed from personal phone BEFORE adding to company phone.

So it took me quite a few hours to sort it out with IT admin.

---------- try 1: failed

delete MFA on my 365 account

log in to 365 admin portal -> Top right "View account" -> "Security Info" on the left hand side

or https://mysignins.microsoft.com/security-info

you should be able to see this to delete MFA

But I can't! to see this page I need the code from authenticator. so failed

---------- try 2: failed

disable MFA on Azure Porta with IT admin help

https://portal.azure.com/#view/Microsoft_AAD_UsersAndTenants/UserManagementMenuBlade/~/AllUsers

Azure Portal -> Search for "Microsoft Entra ID" -> Left menu "Users" -> Per-User MFA

But again, I don't have permission, so ask IT admin for help, below is what he can see:

And it turned out that MFA is disabled for everyone. :(

---------- try 3: failed

Security Defaults or Conditional Access

Searched it up and found some threads that might help:

https://video2.skills-academy.com/en-us/answers/questions/23371/how-to-disable-mfa-from-azure-ad

From Azure Portal -> Searched for "Microsoft Entra ID" -> in the "Overview" page -> there is a tab in the middle "Properties" -> "Security defaults" underneath

it's disabled already and "Save" button is greyed out, I cannot do anything about it.

IT admin don't want to apply any new rule/policy across all staffs in the company either.

So failed again.

---------- try 4: Success !!!

Finally it turned out I don't have phone or email set up in my profile.

To find out:

https://portal.azure.com/#view/Microsoft_AAD_UsersAndTenants/UserManagementMenuBlade/~/AllUsers

Azure Portal -> Search for "Microsoft Entra ID" -> Left menu "Users" -> Search for your email address -> Authentication methods

Again I don't have permission to change anything for my Azure account. Asked for IT's help. They can see below, and do it for you:

Once your phone number added, try logging in to 365 admin portal -> Top right "View account" -> "Security Info" again

or https://mysignins.microsoft.com/security-info

You will see the annoying dialog again to ask you to Open your authenticator app and enter the number shown.

But his time is quite different after clicking "I can't use my Microsoft Authenticator app right now"

You will see

Yeah!!!!

And then go back to "Security Info" and you can delete MFA by yourself. Hahahahah !!!